This first went out to the Better Bass Lessons email list on August 15, 2026. Want the next one? Join the list here. It’s free.
Herbie Hancock tells this story about a chord he played that was just so wrong.
He’s a young guy, in his early twenties, a couple of years into playing piano in Miles Davis’s band. The best band on the planet at the time. In his memoir, Possibilities, he puts it at a concert hall in Stockholm in the mid-1960s. Tony Williams is on drums, Wayne Shorter’s on saxophone, and Ron Carter, who taught me at Juilliard, is on bass. They’re playing “So What,” and the show is heating up.
Miles is building up to his solo. He takes a breath. And right then Herbie plays the chord. Wrong chord, wrong place. It’s live, it’s already in the air, and there’s no taking it back. He told CBS it felt like he’d just destroyed a house of cards.
What Miles did with the wrong chord
Here’s what Miles does.
Nothing, for a fraction of a second. Then he plays a few notes, and those notes bend the harmony around until Herbie’s horrible chord makes sense. In Herbie’s words, Miles “plays some notes that somehow, miraculously, make my chord sound right.” In real time, in front of the whole audience, Miles reaches out and makes the wrong thing right.
Herbie says his mouth fell open. Miles took off into his solo, and the crowd went crazy. After the show, Herbie asked him about it in the dressing room. Miles just winked. He didn’t say a word.
It took Herbie years to work out what had happened. He’s put it like this: “Miles didn’t hear it as a mistake. He heard it as something that happened.” And another time: “It took me years to realize Miles didn’t judge my chord, I did.”
What a good ear does when the music goes wrong
Miles could do that because his ear was so far ahead of his hands that a surprise wasn’t a threat. It was just more information.
Somebody hands him a wrong chord? Fine. He hears where it wants to go and takes it there.
Now picture that same moment with most players. A wrong chord lands and the whole thing falls apart, because their only plan was the right notes. The second reality goes off the script, they’ve got nothing. No way to hear their way back.
That’s the difference an ear makes, and it has nothing to do with avoiding mistakes. Mistakes are coming no matter what. The singer jumps in early. The guitarist blanks on the bridge. Or you fluff a note yourself. The ear doesn’t stop any of that. The ear is what lets you catch it and land on your feet, instead of freezing and praying the tune ends soon.
How to start building that ear
You can’t read your way to that. There’s no chart for “the thing that just went wrong.” You can only hear your way to it.
So learn your next tune by ear. Sing it, find it on the piano, then play it on your bass. I walk through that process in how to learn jazz standards on bass. Every tune you learn that way builds the thing that lets you respond to a song instead of just executing one.
Go deeper
Play What You Hear
Six lessons on learning songs by ear: sing it, find it on the piano, then play it on your instrument.
